Friday, October 12, 2007

Apa yg kita pertikai?

Kita pertikaikan kenyataan anaianai yg kerajaan Ayuthia itu adalah Siam Islam.
Dlm 3 artikel terbaru anaianai (sebenarnya bukan artikel, tapi merupakan copy paste), tak ada satu hujah pun yg menyokong dakwaan bahawa raja-raja Ayutthaya itu adalah Islam.
Malah dlm artikel anaianai Great Qing and Its Southern Neighbors, 1760-1820 dlm satu perenggan itu ada menyatakan Ayutthaya mengamalkan Bhuddism..

...From the early 1400's on the kings of Siam, with their capital at Ayutthaya not far north of Bangkok, promoted and controlled maritime trade as a source of revenue that would give them a political edge over regional leaders whose main resource was levies of soldiers out of the populous rice lands. Chinese sojourning and settling in Siam could begin to fit in to Siamese society, with its rice agriculture, Buddhism, and substantial monarchy, without having to confront any differences as great as those they encountered in Muslim societies9....
Pasal bunuh berbunuhan itu, memang tidak dinafikan pada zaman dahulu berlaku perebutan tahta, kesultanan Melayu sendiri pun ada kejadian begini.
Dlm kes Ayuthaya, dlm satu peristiwa dikatakan 2 org putera(adik beradik) bertarung atas gajah berebut tahta yg berkesudahan kedua-duanya mati atas belakang gajah masing-masing.

No comments: